What is a Balk in Baseball?

A balk is an illegal act by the pitcher when runners are on base intended to deceive the baserunners. According to the Official Baseball Rules, a balk occurs when the pitcher makes any motion naturally associated with his pitch while not actually making a pitch.

Definition of a Balk

Specifically, a balk is called when:

Effect of a Balk

The effect of a balk being called by the umpire depends on the situation:

So in summary, a balk is an illegal act by the pitcher designed to deceive runners. It is called by the umpire when the pitcher makes a deceitful movement on the mound and does not deliver the pitch. When called, all runners on base advance one base automatically.

The Balk: Baseball’s Trickiest Rule

Overview of the Balk Rule

The balk is one of baseball’s most confusing and controversial rules. It is called when a pitcher makes an illegal motion during his delivery to home plate, intending to deceive the baserunners. Determining what constitutes a balk has frustrated players, coaches, umpires and fans for over 100 years. The balk rule aims to protect batters from unfair deceit by the pitcher, but remains one of baseball’s least understood regulations.

Origins of the Balk Rule

The balk rule was instituted in 1898. Prior to that, pitchers could legally make feints and abrupt starts and stops in their delivery to confuse batters and runners. The new rule banned these deceptive tactics, requiring pitchers to come to a complete stop before throwing home. Over time, more specific pitcher motions were deemed illegal balks as well.

Main Types of Balks

Starting and Stopping Delivery

Once a pitcher begins his motion towards home plate, he must complete the delivery or risk a balk call. Stopping mid-windup is prohibited unless reacting to an external distraction.

Faking a Throw to a Base

Pitchers can feint throws to bases to try to pick off runners, but cannot pump or snap their shoulders without actually making a throw. This incomplete throwing motion is an illegal balk.

Not Stepping Toward a Base

Pitchers must step directly toward a base before throwing there. Turning or spinning off the rubber prior to stepping towards the base constitutes a balk.

Quick Pitching

The pitcher cannot deliver the pitch until the batter has time to get set in the box. Even with no runners on base, there must be a one second pause between pitches.

Not Pausing in Set Position

From the set position, pitchers must come to a complete stop for at least one second before starting their delivery. Failure to pause is an automatic balk.

Separating Hands During Set

After setting their hands together, pitchers cannot separate them before starting the pitch. Any drifting of the hands apart while setting is a balk.

Dropping the Ball

If a pitcher drops the ball while on the rubber, a balk is immediately called. The pitcher must maintain control of the ball while on the mound.

The Ongoing Balk Controversy

Over 100 years later, the balk remains one of baseball’s most misunderstood and controversial rules. The complexity continues to frustrate players, coaches and fans alike. However, the rule persists in the name of maintaining fairness and preventing pitcher deception.

The Balk: Baseball’s Most Confusing Call : What Constitutes a Balk

Illegal Motions

The official rules list more than half a dozen actions that could result in a balk being called, from failing to come to a complete stop during a stretch to making a quick pitch without allowing the batter to get set in the box. The nuances of what is and isn’t allowed mid-windup are complex and even many veteran players and fans don’t fully understand them.

Judgment Calls

Umpires are tasked with making this judgment call in real time, adding to the trouble. Given the speed of MLB pitches, it’s reasonable that not every infraction will be caught. Pitchers often get away with small mistakes. But when a balk is called, especially at a critical moment, it can be infuriating for players and managers who feel the call was incorrect.

Consequences of a Balk

Since it results in a dead ball, any pitch thrown is voided, even if the batter puts it in play. Runners on base at the time are all awarded an automatic one base advance. So if the bases were loaded, a balk would drive in a run. Needless to say, this can drastically impact a game.

Calls for Change

MLB has made some minor tweaks to balk rules over the years in attempts to add clarity. However, the basic framework has remained in place for decades. There have been calls to simplify or even eliminate balk rules entirely, but baseball has been reluctant to make major changes to this integral, if misunderstood, part of the game.

A Constant Concern

For pitchers, the threat of a balk is a constant concern. Fans are left hoping questionable calls don’t affect crucial games. And umpires must make split-second decisions knowing many will criticize their judgement. The balk may frustrate all involved, but it remains a core element of baseball’s unique set of quirks and intricacies.

Avoiding Balks : Establish a Consistent Routine

Practice the Same Timing and Motion

Pitchers need to establish a rhythmic and repeatable routine on the mound when pitching out of the stretch. This includes when to look at runners on base, how to come set, and having the same leg kick and delivery. By repeating the same cadence and timing, pitchers are less likely to make an illegal motion that crosses up their normal pitching delivery. Practicing a set routine in bullpen sessions is important to commit it to muscle memory.

Use the Same Ritual Between Pitches

Having a detailed routine between pitches can help pitchers repeat their mechanics and avoid rushing. This can include how they receive the ball from the catcher, glance at baserunners, grip the ball, and step on the rubber. Standardizing the process between each pitch will lead to consistency.

Properly Step Off the Rubber

Disengage the Rubber with the Pivot Foot

Before attempting a throw over to a base or faking a pickoff move, pitchers must completely disengage the rubber. This means stepping backwards off the pitching rubber with their pivot foot first. The foot must clearly leave contact with the rubber before making any moves towards a base. After stepping off, the pitcher can throw or fake a throw to any base.

Step Off Cleanly Before Any Movements

Pitchers cannot make any motions towards a pickoff until their pivot foot has left the rubber. A beanball pitch or flinching before stepping off can still be called a balk. Keep the disengagement crisp before making pickoff attempts.

Come Set Before Pitching

Stop Completely in the Set Position

Pitchers must come to a complete stop in the set position before beginning their pitching delivery. This means stopping for at least one second with hands together and feet stationary. No pitching motions can begin until fully set. Coming set with a consistent rhythm can help avoid rushing and making multiple movements.

Hands Together and Feet Planted

To be deemed properly set, pitchers must have their hands together and feet firmly on the ground. Glove and throwing hands should be touching and feet cannot be moving or bouncing. This pause demonstrates control before starting the pitch.

Keep Hands Together When Set

No Separating Until the Pitching Motion

After coming set, pitchers must keep their hands together until separating them as part of the pitch delivery. Any illegal motions such as swinging the glove hand towards second base can be called a balk. Keep the hands still and together until beginning the natural pitching motion.

Avoid Deceptive Movements

Pitchers cannot make any motion that looks like the start of a pitch before actually delivering the ball. These can include taking the hands apart, a glove flick, shoulder turn or bringing the leg up. Keep everything paused until committing to the full pitching movement.

Only Throw to Occupied Bases

Fakes and Throws Only to Runners

It can be tempting to try to deceive runners by faking throws to unoccupied bases. However, any step or throw towards a base without a runner will be called a balk. Pitchers can only make live ball throws or fakes to bases currently occupied by baserunners.

No Deceiving Unoccupied Bases

Even if not intended to deceive, throwovers or pickoff attempts to bases with no runners are prohibited. Pitchers must clearly step off the rubber first, then can only make moves to bases with runners actually on them. Limit pickoff and hold moves to legitimate threats.

New Plan Seeks to Limit Balk Call Appeals: Background on Balk Rules

Definition of a Balk

A balk occurs when a pitcher makes an illegal motion on the mound that could deceive a base runner. This includes things like failing to come to a set position, making a quick pitch, or dropping the ball during the pitch.

Controversial Nature of Balk Calls

Balk calls are often controversial as the rules contain a lot of nuance. Determining a balk frequently relies on the umpire’s judgment of whether a deception occurred. Managers frequently appeal balk rulings.

Details of the Proposed Plan

Limits on Appeals and Challenges

The new rule would prohibit teams from using replay review or manager challenges to appeal balk calls. Umpires would have final authority on their initial balk ruling.

Umpire Discretion to Reverse Calls

While appeals would be limited, the plan allows umpires to reverse their own balk calls after consulting with other umpires. This retains a human element in enforcing the rules.

Perspectives on the Rule Change Proposal

Supporters Argue It Will Speed Up Games

Proponents believe the plan will reduce unnecessary delays from balk appeals, improving pace of play.

Opponents Worry About Accountability

Critics argue the inability to appeal judgement calls sets a bad precedent and reduces umpire accountability.

Let me know if you would like me to modify or expand on any part of the article outline.


Last News